Our Trusted Carriers

We have curated our list of carriers to provide the best partnerships in protecting your assets. Our carriers are all AM Best A- or better. This ensures that we are placing your valuables in a financially sound company, so when you need to pay a claim, you are can rest easy knowing that you will be covered. 

Traditional Property / Casualty Partners


AEGIS

Claims: 1 (800) 233-2160

Service: 1 (800) 233-2160

American Modern

Claims: 1 (800) 375-2075

Service: 1 (800) 543-2644

AmTrust Financial

Claims: 1 (844) 451-0750

Service: 1 (877) 528-7878

Allstate

Claims: 1 (800) 255-7828

Service: 1 (800) 255-7828

Berkshire Hathaway GUARD

Claims: 1 (800) 673-2465

Service: 1 (800) 673-2465

Celina Insurance Group

Claims: 1 (800) 231-2318

Service: 1 (800) 552-5181

Central Insurance Companies

Claims: 1 (888) 263-2924

Service: 1 (800) 786-9052

Dairyland Auto

Claims: 1 (800) 334-0090

Service: 1 (800) 334-0090

Donegal Insurance Group

Claims: 1 (800) 877-9006

Service: 1 (800) 877-0600

Encompass

Claims: 1 (800) 588-7400

Service: 1 (800) 262-7255

FCCI Insurance Group

Claims: 1 (800) 226-3224

Service: 1 (800) 226-3224

Foremost Insurance Group

Claims: 1 (800) 527-3907

Service: 1 (800) 527-3905

Grange Insurance

Claims: 1 (800) 445-3030

Service: 1 (800) 422-0550

Hagerty

Claims: 1 (800) 385-0274

Service: 1 (877) 922-9701

Liberty Mutual Insurance (including former Safeco)

Claims: 1 (800) 225-2467

Service: 1 (800) 290-8711

MAPFRE Insurance

Claims: 1 (877) 224-5677

Service: 1 (877) 224-5677

Merchants Insurance Group (Business Insurance)

Claims: 1 (800) 952-5246

Service: 1 (800) 462-1077

Farmers GroupSelect (formerly MetLife Auto & Home)

Claims: 1 (800) 422-4272

Service: 1 (800) 422-4272

Millers Mutual

Claims: 1 (800) 745-4555

Service: 1 (888) 714-7313

National General Insurance

Claims: 1 (800) 468-3466

Service: 1 (888) 293-5108

NatGen Premier

Claims: 1 (844) 287-2236

Service: 1 (844) 287-2237

Nationwide

Claims: 1 (800) 421-3535

Service: 1 (877) 669-6877

Ohio Mutual Insurance Group

Claims: 1 (888) 895-7725

Service: 1 (800) 686-3011

1859 Mutual (formerly Pike Mutual)

Claims: 1 (800) 342-2521

Service: 1 (800) 342-2521

State Auto (a Liberty Mutual company)

Claims: 1 (877) 722-5246

Service: 1 (800) 492-5351

Travelers

Claims: 1 (800) 252-4633

Service: 1 (888) 564-5043

Trexis

Claims: 1 (877) 384-7466

Service: 1 (877) 384-7466

Utica First Insurance Company

Claims: 1 (800) 456-4556

Service: 1 (800) 456-4556

Utica National Insurance Group

Claims: 1 (800) 216-1420

Service: 1 (800) 598-8422

Western Reserve Group

Claims: 1 (800) 362-0426

Service: 1 (800) 362-0426

Westfield Insurance

Claims: 1 (800) 243-0210

Service: 1 (800) 243-0210

Wholesale, Specialty & Premium Finance Partners


Burns & Wilcox

Service: 1 (248) 932-9000

Capital Premium Financing (Premium Finance)

Claims: 1 (800) 767-0705

Service: 1 (800) 767-0705

RPS (Risk Placement Services)

Claims: 1 (844) 777-8323

Service: 1 (866) 595-8413

Specialty Underwriters Group (SUG)

Service: 1 (800) 844-1815

Life and Financial Services Partners


BUA (Business Underwriters Associates)

Claims: 1 (800) 792-6795

Service: 1 (800) 792-6795

Crump Life Insurance Services

Claims: See Website

Service: See Website

MetLife (Life)

Claims: 1 (800) 854-6011

Service: 1 (800) 422-4272

Nationwide (Life)

Claims: 1 (800) 848-6331

Service: 1 (800) 848-6331

Our Affiliations

Our membership in SIAA gives us access to more carriers and resources on your behalf.

SIAA (Strategic Insurance Agency Alliance)

United Group Alliance (SIAA Ohio)

Phone: 1 (888) 783-8773

Call 614-445-0610Get a Quote